© 2023 by SRSM. All copyrights owned by SRSM unless otherwise stated

  • Facebook Social Icon
  • Twitter Social Icon
  • Instagram Social Icon
Nov 1

The Politics of Workers' Control....part 2

0 comments

Edited: Nov 1

So as republican socialists we should promote a real alternative.

And I have been looking at length at the writings of Hal Draper, an American Marxist -an innovative, independently minded thinker.

Draper says that throughout history the real division in socialism had not been so much the division between reformism and revolution.

The real division has been the one between socialism from above and socialism from below.

His TWO SOULS OF SOCIALISM which came out in 1966 says social democracy -i.e. Fabianism/Labourism/the Morrisonian model- on the one hand and Stalinism on the other have much in common despite the obvious differences.

*They share a distrust of the working class

*Workers aren't viewed as being capable of creating a new society on their own initiative

*Socialism must be handed down to the masses by a ruling elite

*Socialism is about what the state does for workers supposedly for their benefit and on their behalf.

Socialism from below -by contrast- is about workers self emancipation.

*Mobilising through struggle

*Workers as actors, not subjects

*Taking charge of their own destiny

And it is the whole notion, Draper says, of WORKERS' CONTROL, what were are talking about here today, that distinguishes grassroots socialism -organised from below- from discredited top down socialism from above.

New Posts
  • The Rent Strike is a method of protest commonly employed against large landlords. Generally a group of tenants come together and refuse payment until a specific demand is met. It an be a useful tactic as a last resort. In 1915 there was a massive rent strike in Glasgow. One of the leaders was Mary Barbour. She and an "army" of supporters pelted bailiffs trying to enter tenements with flour bombs. In the end the Government relented and on 27 November 1915 legislation was introduced restricting rents to the pre-war level. Sean Damer (1996) compares the 1915 rent strikes to the struggles in the late 1980s and early 1990's against the poll tax. Both are depicted as popular movements championing justice.
  • A Citizens' Incoem is an "unconditional, automatic and non-withdrawable payment to each individual as a right of citizenship" (Cunningham 2015). The advantages of a CI are that it helps ameliorate "poverty and unemployment traps", it provides a safety net for all and that it contributes to social cohesion. Plus, based as it is on citizenship, it is simpler and easier to administer than means tested systems. Cunningham (2015) argues that a CI could be financed by "removing tax allowances and reducing means testing and most contributory benefits." Funding could also come courtesy of for instance a land value tax, a carbon tax and/or a "Tobin Tax." The idea is that there would be three levels of CI -a children's level, standard adult level and a retiree's level. People with a disability would receive a supplement and there would have to be a London weighting. More information can be found at www.citizenincome.org
  • Tom Leonard was born in Glasgow on 22 August 1944. His father was a train driver from Dublin who came to Scotland in 1916 in search of work. His mother -of Irish descent- was from Saltcoats and had worked in the Nobel dynamite factory at Ardeer before getting married. After leaving school Tom worked as a bus driver and university bookshop assistant. He also went to night school and then to Glasgow University when he was 23. There he edited the student magazine. He left after two years but went back in the 1970s to finish his degree. Since then he has made his living as a writer. He ha had Scottish Arts Council Bursaries and was Writer in Residence at Renfrewshire libraries. Whilst there he completed an anthology of local poets called RADICAL RENFREW. In 2001 together with Alisdair Gray and James Kelman he was appointed Joint Professor in Creative Writing back at Glasgow University. He retired in 2009. Tom has written plays, poetry and political polemic and also a biography PLACES OF THE MIND about James "B.V. Thomson." Where poetry is concerned Tom is best known for writing in the "phonetically transcribed urban Glasgow dialect." In doing this he has sought to challenge "deeply held prejudices against the urban vernacular" (Broom 2006). He has previously said he'd "like a Scottish independent socialist republic" and spoke out against both the Gulf and Iraq wars. would thi prisoner in thi bar please stand ..... I hearby sentence you tay six munth hard labour doon nthi poetry section uv yir local library coontn thi fuckin metaphors (From Leonard's poem "Ghostie Men").